Federal hst vs speer gold dot 9mm. 2" and also expands to .

Federal hst vs speer gold dot 9mm. My agency just started allowing us to personally acquire two very particular types of ammo: Hornady 9mm+P 135gr Critical Duty [90226] Speer 147gr Gold Dot G2 [24226] These both perform well from what I've read, but which do you recommend for a Glock 19 versus a smaller-barreled pistol (for example, Sig P365 or Glock 26)? I've read that Critical Duty is better Aug 1, 2012 · I'm looking using federal hst or speer gold dot both in 230gr. Range ammo is whatever brass case is cheap from 115 on up. Back when I carried an XD Mod. I've pretty much decided on Speer's Gold Dot, either in the 124 grain non+p or the 124gr grain +p. ) and leaning toward the Federal HST. Hornady Critical Duty +P in 135 grain 9mm was very comfortable to shoot out of my PM9. 40 S&W, . Find the perfect balance for safety and training! Federal HST vs. It’s important to understand that if your round over penetrates a barrier or your target and impacts a bystander, as a civilian that criminal and civil liability is 100% yours. 380 based on a lot of reading, however now that I've switched carry guns I may go with 147 grain in the Shield, time will tell. Oct 7, 2020 · The three most popular premium JHP rounds. The G2 has actually been around since 2014 or so, long enough for tactical Jun 21, 2025 · Gold Dots in 124gr and 147gr are inherently accurate, same for the HST but it seems the Speer GD is the gun's preference. I have been using HCD but the Gold Dot seems to be preferred by a couple friends of mine. Like the Sig Sauer V-Crown ammo, the Federal HST 9mm 124-grain load has demonstrated near-perfect performance in terms of expansion and penetration. The originals and G2 perform slightly differently. All are premium bullets, and all have excellent reputations. The other one, which is my #1 choice in 9mm, is the Winchester Ranger SXT 127 Grain. The next best functioning in all my pistols is Remington Golden Saber. Jan 27, 2023 · Best carry round for a 9mm with a 3" barrel? Federal HST? Gold dots? Gold dot short barrel? What grain? Why? Thanks! Jul 30, 2022 · I use the Speer Gold Dot 124+p in all my 9mm guns. Jul 16, 2018 · Federal HST 124-grain The Federal Premium HST 124-grain was plenty accurate. Buy Speer Gold Dot 9mm 124 Grain +P JHP Online Now! Ammunition Depot offers a wide selection of bulk ammo for game, target practice, and self-defense. Both boast excellent reputations, but understanding their key differences can help you make an informed choice based on your specific needs Jul 14, 2017 · Comparing different 9mm ammo (Gold Dot, Federal, Hornady. Throwaway for anonymous reasons. Federal HST and HydraShock come up a lot too. Today we are testing the Speer Gold Dot, Federal HST, Winchester Defender (Ranger) and Hornady Critical Duty in a 10% Clear ballistics test with rib simulation and 4 layers of sweatshirt as well I'm an HST guy but will use Gold Dot as well. Jan 22, 2025 · I’m good with either 124 or 147 from the major manufacturers. That's my #1 reason for carrying HST between the two rounds - it's easier on the wallet, and I'm more willing to shoot them occasionally to keep in practice. The specific bullet matters more than the weight; although 115 tends to under perform regardless of the maker. Speer Gold Dot vs Federal HST Ballistic Gel Test & Review 9mm +P 9x19 Buckeye Ballistics 74. Secret Service and many PDs; NYPD uses Gold Dot; the U. While no single load reigns supreme, careful consideration of ballistics, accuracy, reliability, and personal preference is critical to finding the optimal 9mm ammunition for your specific needs. I use 124gr hst a quick comparison between speer gdhp 124gr 1150fps and speer gdhp 147gr 985fps. American Rifleman is HST can be found in "law enforcement" 50 packs for less money than a regular box of Speer Gold Dots. Speer Gold DotRe: Federal HST vs. It does what Speer says it does and does what many companies wish their products did. 3" and an expansion of . Speer is also a high quality ammo company and has always been reliable, accurate and consistent in my testings, (actually same parent Co. The . Speer Gold DotAs the title suggests, I'm curious about people's experiences with the two listed rounds for self-defense/carry ammo. My ranking : 1) Federal HTS , 2) Speer GD 3) Hornady Critical Defense (not Duty). You can buy hotter +P ammo if you want more power. Which one looks like the best expansion? Reason I ask, I'm trying to consolidate and settle on one, sell the rest. com. May 26, 2017 · Remington Golden Saber, Winchester Ranger and Speer Gold Dot loads have all been quite reliable and accurate in my guns, but have given somewhat less impressive results in reported gelatin testing for expansion and/or penetration, so I'm content with the standard Federal 230gr HST load for CCW. Posted by u/zeuskab00s - 1 vote and no comments Ballistics gel test in 9mm between federal HST 124g, Speer gold dot 124 & 147g, Winchester 147g defend ammo. I've heard that the 124 grain 9mm+p gold dot is the chosen carry load for various police departments and even some federal agencies, is this Aug 25, 2011 · Federal HST vs Speer Gold Dot 9mm Jump to Latest 7. 45 acp +p Speer Gold Dot VS Federal HST in ballistics gel May 14, 2012 · So far, I've narrowed it down to the 124gr Federal HST JHP and the 124gr Speer Gold Dot JHP, both standard pressure. Using the glock 26 to send them Sep 24, 2021 · I did ballistic gel tests of Speer Gold Dot 124 and 147gr and Winchester 124gr and published the results in another thread. Not sure the difference between them and HST, but compared to 124+p Gold dot, 115 critical defense, and 124 Punch it gave me my best grouping with fastest follow up shots, so I chose it. Double Tap Ammo has a 9mm +P 124 gr JHP load that gives an even 1,300 fps. 2" and also expands to . Bigger and has some pretty gnarly barbs on I'm considering going to that but I'm wondering if the only reason it opened so much is because its +P+. I consider those industry standard and they both work in 100% in my SD carry gun. I currently am carrying 147g HST in my Glock 26, but I also have 124g +P Gold Dots that I will carry in the summer. law enforcement, and what sets each apart. And Speer knows it, which is why it began looking for a successor a few years ago. Weird that the 124gr's expansion diameter is the same as the 147gr - why is that? 9mm speer gold dot VS federal hst 124 grain +p AZ Airgunner 8. He knows at what velocities the gold dot 124gr performs well. The Speer Gold Dot +P was more recoil. For civilian defensive use, the best performers are Federal HST, Speer Gold Dot and Sig V-Crown. After all, I do spend a lot of time here, and so does my family. There are many other brands you can try & share your thoughts. Reply reply Aug 15, 2023 · The main difference between Speer Gold Dot and Hornady Critical Duty ammunition lies in their design philosophies and intended purposes. How fast can you shoot 3 rounds of 124 +p vs 147? How tight are your groups at speed? From what I've seen the performance betwee the two isn't dramatically different, but the recoil impulse is noticeable. From left to right: Gold Dot, HST, Talon. While both are popular self-defense ammunition options, they have distinct characteristics. Feb 18, 2012 · I would trust any of the loads from Federal HST, Speer Gold Dot, or Winchester T-series in any bullet size and any caliber. 38 special revolvers. Taurus GX4 test shoot: Vista Outdoors 124 gr 9mm +P, Federal HST vs Speer Gold Dot - Ballistic Gel Mar 28, 2025 · For example, Speer Gold Dot and Winchester bonded (PDX1) were adopted by the FBI at various times; Federal HST is used by the U. Federal HST 124gr and Speer Gold Dot 124gr for daily carry. 357 Sig ammo from Speer and Federal. Ballistics show the HST 124gr to have a penetrating depth of 18. May 26, 2022 · Compare the performance of two popular JHP rounds for self-defense: Federal HST and Speer Gold Dot. Jan 16, 2024 · In order to detail the difference of the carbine-specific Speer Gold Dot ammo, I tested it against the excellent Federal HST Deep 135-grain JHP round. Two top contenders frequently debated are the Federal HST and the Speer Gold Dot. Having seen vehicle barrier penetration tests with both, I would be perfectly ok with HST 147gr too instead even with it's mechanical bonding. 45 ACP is Better than the 9mm and that's NO Fuddlore Speer Gold Dot vs Speer G2 - What's The Difference? (9mm vs 40s&w) . They list the "Critical Defense" 9mm and 9mm+P as surpassing all FBI test requirements and their choice for the AOY list. 223, HST . Dec 16, 2024 · Just ran across this new video comparing the 124gr HST to 124gr Gold Dots - HSTs are my go-to for . Jul 5, 2018 · I prefer to carry the Federal HST 230gr +p . May 12, 2019 · Five of the contenders, Federal Premium HST JHP, Speer Gold Dot +P “Short Barrel” JHP, Hornady XTP +P JHP, Winchester PDX1 Defender +P and Buffalo Bore +P+ JHP all weigh 124 grains. If I could reliably find Speer Lawman TMJ rounds for range trips, I would probably fully switch to Gold Dots because the Lawman rounds are very, very close to their hollow point cousin in terms of POI. Originally, Gold Dot’s claim to fame was law enforcement use in 9mm and . 147 grain just didn't feed well in my Kahr PM9, that's the only reason I went with 124 grain. 61". Speer Gold Dot +P I really like the Speer Gold Dot +P, 200 grain rounds. Army adopted a special Winchester 9mm JHP for its new M17 pistols. S. HydraShok is typically cheaper than HST as well, so with it performing well on tests I’m confident in it. Strange thing is every time I read about an NYPD shooting including recently, their 124gr gold dot did the job in 1-2 shots in almost Dec 8, 2024 · Its either Speer Gold Dot or Federal HST for me, in 9mm, . 2 chambered in 45 ACP, these were my go-to self-defense rounds. May 27, 2020 · I take my home defense strategy very seriously. Three shots of each cartridge were fired from 10 feet away into Knox ballistic gelatin blocks. See how they differ in penetration, expansion, compatibility, and casing quality in a ballistic test. Bullet Similarities And Differences I currently run 9mm 147gr HST (standard pressure, not +P or +P+) in my CCW (CZ P-01). Which one is the best choice? Heavy clothing ballistic gel test using a Glock 19!Join this channel to become a memb Dec 26, 2024 · Table of Contents Choosing the right self-defense ammunition is a critical decision, demanding careful consideration of various factors. 2K subscribers Subscribed I get the same comment a lot, that ALL 9mm ammo performs well, so buying Federal HST or Speer Gold Dot is a waste of money. No doubt Gold Dot and HST are considered top of the line ammo and you cannot go wrong with either. I strictly avoid the light, solid copper bullets, but all the good Oct 7, 2020 · I’ve seen couple people shot with Gold Dot and HST out of 9mm. Sep 16, 2024 · This comparison focused on 9mm +P performance in bare ballistic gelatin between Underwood Ammo’s Xtreme Defender line, Speer Gold Dot, and Federal HST. Nov 11, 2024 · I'm looking at both Speer Gold Dot and Federal HST loads to carry for self-defense, and I've got three 9mm guns to use: CZ P10F, Glock 45, and a Glock 26. out of my P365 but the Speer GD load comes very close in performance. Also, Federal Syntech defense 138gr frangible if you plan to use the gun for home defense. I put that to the test by compari Jan 1, 2015 · I found 500 rounds of Federal Premium law enforcement HST 124 grain for $140 on gunbroker recently. I'm wondering which of those two bullet weights you prefer, and why. Carry ammo is usually 124+p Gold Dots or HST, or 147 HST. as Federal). Apr 13, 2023 · We collected a broad selection of 9mm Luger ammunition for this Gun Tests+ comparison. 15K subscribers 1. When a shooter talks about the best 9mm ammo brands, Federal HST and Speer Gold Dot remain their top-tier options. Two leading contenders frequently top the lists: Speer Gold Dot and Federal HST. Nov 29, 2011 · I have done tons of research and decided on 4 carry rounds 1 Federal HST 124gr +p 2 Federal HST 147gr 3 Speer Gold dot 124gr +p 4 Speer Gold dot 147gr what one would you pick and why? Jan 30, 2010 · Speer GDHP ammo is one of the two I consider top-notch 9mm SD ammo. 83K subscribers Subscribe Feb 28, 2003 · Conversely , Speer GD 9mm 124 gr. 124 gr. Shopping for the Gold Dot Handgun Personal Protection, 9mm Luger, 124 Grain, Gold Dot Hollow Point, 1150 fps - Learn more about the latest Gold Dot Handgun Personal Protection and other hunting, shooting or reloading gear at Speer. Which one is the best? Heavy clothing ballistic gel test using a Glock 33!Join this channel to become a Comparing two different Gold Dot weights. Feb 10, 2018 · Federal HST's or Speer Gold Dot 124 grain plus P ? Jump to Latest 11K views 14 replies 6 participants last post by little_scrapper Mar 13, 2018 Canyon Man Discussion starter 9mm ammo debate 124gr vs 124gr +P So after all my research I could find on 124gr and 124gr +P (specifically federal HST and speer gold dot) I've came to the conclusion that it's not worth it to buy the +P ammo. "tnoutdoors9" rated the Federal HST 124g slightly ahead of the Speer Gold Dot 124g, but recommended both as suitable defense ammo. While the CD is not loaded as hot. FirearmsTactical. Oct 28, 2020 · Here's an overview of the five best 9mm self defense rounds used by U. But my point is that if a second tier hollow point worked well in combat then I'm sure either of these rounds will work effectively for you during a gas station robbery. 61" while the HST 147gr penetrates 15. May 24, 2025 · Comparing some . The Walther PDP-F test gun provided good accuracy and faultless reliability. They expand reliably and penetrate consistently. The one round that impressed me for expansion/damage, good enough penetration without overpenetration as the Federal HST May 5, 2009 · I use Glock 26, and was wondering if anyone has experience, test results, problems, or recommendations for the 9mm Federal HST LE +P vs the 9mm Speer Gold DOt for short barrell. 45ACP rounds in my S&W MP45 mid-size for daily carry and the Speer 124gr +p 9mm rounds in my 9s, but I've found absolutely nothing wrong whatsoever with the Speer 147gr G2 9mm rounds. Speer Gold Dot: Choosing the Right Self-Defense Ammo Choosing the right self-defense ammunition is a critical decision, impacting your safety and well-being. Honestly, I can't tell the difference between them but for the price I thought the rounds I found were a great value. In searching other forums, I hear some negatives about the Federal not retaining petals in test, particularly the 124 Apr 30, 2013 · The round on the left is SPEER Gold Dot 124gr GDHP and the one on the right is Federal 124gr +P+ HST due to the fact that the federal opens so much. Dec 18, 2024 · In this article, we go over a little shopping tip that can help you save some coin when it comes to buying defensive 9mm ammo. Feb 8, 2025 · Selecting premium defensive ammunition for self-defense or law enforcement use is crucial. Federal HST vs. Most lived. Nov 7, 2012 · Hello all I performed a performance test on four 9mm hollow points and wold like to share the results. I'd be happy with either, I just prefer the +P loadings. Click to expand The HST has been used in actual police involved shootings. 6K Jun 13, 2023 · What's better for self-defense - Hornady Critical Defense vs Federal HST? We test both at the range with gel testing to help you pick. Hollow Point Dec 21, 2024 · Comparing Federal HST and Speer Gold Dot 124 grain +P 9MM ammo. Ammunition lines like Federal’s Hydra-Shok and HST, Speer’s Gold Dot and Gold Dot G2, and Hornady’s Critical Defense and Critical Duty are among the most trusted names in personal protection. This is a new bullet. Jul 16, 2022 · First Ballistic Gel Test! 9mm 124gr Speer Gold Dot vs Federal HST Andrew Conrad 27. Jan 31, 2023 · Just curious for those of you that EDC a 380 what you use. 25K subscribers in the concealedcarry community. Sep 7, 2023 · I've been watching some videos on carry ammo, and have really only tried Speer Gold Dot and Federal HST Premium Personal Defense 147gr (9mm) which is what I'm carrying now. . This guide thoroughly examines their historical background, technical characteristics, field performance Apr 28, 2020 · Within this comparison, I’ll look at the Federal HST, Hydra-Shok and Hydra-Shok Deep; Hornady XTP and FTX; Speer Gold Dot and Gold Dot G2; Winchester Defender; and the Sierra V-Crown—as loaded in the Sig Sauer ammunition line. Dec 17, 2017 · I prefer a full size for home defense. 357 Sig and . Before I listened to the "ultimate ammo quest" I was a Gold Dot guy but I transitioned to the Federal stuff. Save Share Mar 11, 2018 · This gentleman did extensive testing on 9mm ammunition in short barrelled handguns. Buy 124 or 147 in HST or Gold Dot and you'll be in pretty good shape Reply reply Commonwealth-Patriot •. It lacks in expansion when compared to the HST. +p is the load out for most all NYC cops so I'm sure there is enough of a track record to prove Speer GD is a solid choice . Thank you! At The Request Of A Couple Of You Guys, I Re-Tested The Very Popular 9mm 124 Grain Federal HST & The 9mm 124 Grain Speer Gold Dot In Ballistics Gel, This Time With 4 Layers Of Denim. 2K subscribers Subscribe For my carry setup: P365X - HST 124Gr +P P229 - HST 125Gr LCP II - HST 99Gr I have both the Gold Dot in 9mm 124 +P, and the Gold Dot G2s in 147Gr and carried the Gold Dot +P for a long time but I’ve always been a big fan of the HSTs. I've been doing some research on ammo to feed it for home defense. Enter the Speer Gold Dot G2. Assuming both function properly, which would you choose and why? My local PD uses gold dot in 9mm. May 8, 2012 · I decided on 124 grain standard load Federal HST for my 9mm and 90 grain Federal Hydra-Shok for my . Corbon has a 9mm +P 125 gr JHP load that is rated at 1,250 fps. Federal Premium HST vs Speer Gold Dot! These are two of the best options in 9mm self-defense ammo, but which one is truly the BEST? Heavy clothing ballistic Sep 26, 2021 · Federal HST and Speer Gold Dot are two popular choices for self-defense ammunition. Nov 2, 2008 · Author Topic: Speer Gold Dot JHP VS Federal HST JHP (Read 16469 times) 0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. normal and +p rounds. 99 Available Oct 15, 2015 · Lucky Gunner tests more than 110 different 9mm, 45 ACP, 40 S&W and 380 ACP handgun self-defense ammunition loads in ballistic gel with analysis and video. Personally I do prefer the Federal HST std. I carry 124 HydraShok. i have 124gr Gold Dots but was able to get some 147s for the test. This subreddit is for providing both experienced and inexperienced gun owners a place to discuss all… Dec 23, 2021 · Federal HST, Speer Gold Dot G1, Winchester Ranger Series, Hornady Critical Duty, or loads with Barnes TAC-XP. +p in my PCR, but I've been doing a lot of reading lately about the Federal HST, especially the 147 gr. at 7 yards the 147gr is 312ftlbs 974fps vs 124gr is 354ftlbs 1134fps. com: TacticalBriefs, April 2006 Sep 18, 2020 · To examine what modern personal-defense ammunition looks like, we took a look at three options available from Federal Premium and Speer Ammo. 124gr +p GD and 147gr HST. Will the extra pressure give us different results? Heavy clothing ballistic gel test using a May 17, 2017 · Speer has mastered the art of the 147 grain 9mm with the Gold Dot G2. +P ammo is more expensive, has more recoil, louder, more muzzle flash, and more wear and tear on guns. This in-depth comparison will dissect their performance characteristics, helping you make an informed choice based on your specific needs and preferences. May 5, 2016 · While the Speer Gold Dot 124g had marginally better average expansion, the Federal HST 124g had more uniform expansion and marginally better penetration. Shoot both and see how you feel. Left to right, if were carrying the Federal 124-grain Hydra-Shok, the Federal 124-grain HST, or Speer 124 grain Gold Dot, we would feel well protected. Ammo tested was Speer Gold Dot 147 grain, Federal Tactical HST 124 gr and 147 gr, and Fiocchi Extrema EMB 92 gr. Oct 30, 2019 · The Speer Gold Dot 124-grain 9mm +P has been considered the defensive round against which all others should be judged for almost two decades. vel. Speer pioneered the bonded bullet design with this load, giving shooters a deep-penetrating load retaining its weight, and which didn’t separate when coming into contact with barriers. Aug 1, 2022 · I am currently new to ammo/ self-defense ammunition I am trying to figure out which hollow points are better than the other? I was wondering which one has the better performance 124 grain Federal hst, 124 grain Speer gold dot, or 115 grain critical duty I was wondering which one has a better Feb 26, 2008 · The Speer Gold Dot is one of the 9mm duty rounds that has been a proven performer. See how they compare in terms of velocity, penetration, and expansion in different calibers and barrel lengths. Contemplating switching to 124gr Speer Gold Dot, since technically that's closer what the gun's been tested for (NATO 124gr) without much loss of defensive capability (based on Lucky Gunner's testing). Mar 7, 2025 · Discover the best self-defense ammo for concealed carry: Speer Gold Dot, Federal HST, Hornady, and more. 45 ACP. However, the real kicker is how do they perform in your handgun, and how do you shoot them. Private citizens can purchase Speer Gold Dot and Federal Law Enforcement Tactical HST handgun ammunition directly from Streicher's. I know there is not a right answer :-) and 9mm is better :-) but wondering the thoughts here Mar 13, 2024 · The ‘best’ 9mm handgun ammunition hinges entirely on its intended purpose: self-defense, target practice, competition, or hunting small game. But almost two decades is forever when it comes to ammunition. Dec 4, 2011 · I load both with Speer 9mm 124gr +P Gold Dot JHP ammunition, which I purchase for about $27 per 50 round box from Streicher's PoliceHQ. 45 (230gr) and 9mm (124g). I currently carry "Gold Dot" (GA Arms "new" gold dot ammo) 124 gr. Jan 16, 2011 · For 9mm I load Federal's 9mm +P 124 gr HST ammo, which is rated at an even 1,200 fps, which is only 20 fps more than your Golden Saber +P load. That’s three shots on the left and two on the right. 80% of people shot with handguns apparently do live. I want something with some good stopping power, but concerned with over penetration. Speer Gold Dot « Reply #21 on: March 21, 2012, 07:24:43 AM » Quote from: 1SOW on March 19, 2012, 07:52:28 PM The latest edition of the NRA's Rifleman magazine lists their choice for 'ammo of the year'. For the lead bullets, stick with 124-147gr loadings. I fire one mag of the "good Thank you! Follow me on instagram: / 1shot_tv In This Video I Do The FBI "Heavy Clothing" Ballistics Gel Test With The Federal Premium HST, Speer Gold Dot, & Hornady Critical Duty. 2K views 9 replies 8 participants last post by Jack the Toad Aug 26, 2011 S 124gr vs 124gr +P So after all my research I could find on 124gr and 124gr +P (specifically federal HST and speer gold dot) I've came to the conclusion that it's not worth it to buy the +P ammo. Honestly between Speer, Federal, Winchester, Hornady, and Remington’s good quality stuff there’s not much difference in terms of performance. Jan 22, 2025 · Personally, I usually buy whatever local LE issues and I can afford in enough quantity to both practice with and keep loaded, so depending on caliber and barrel length, I currently have Gold Dot . 40 S&W, Critical Duty 9mm, and Federal Flight Control and TruBall 12 gauge. In this installment, I am testing the Speer Gold Dot 124-grain +P jacketed hollow point bullets, in two versions: regular (part #23617) and Short Barrel (part #23611). Oct 24, 2013 · I have yet to see one recovered from a human body. Gold Dot Handgun Personal Protection, 9mm Luger +P, 124 Grain, Gold Dot Hollow Point, 1220 fps 53617GD $78. 380 auto (Speer Gold Dot VS Federal HST *micro* VS Underwood Xtreme Defender) Ballistics Gel Test AZ Airgunner 8. Seller lives just a half an hour form me. I think his findings and comments on the Speer GDHP in 124gr +p and short barrel apply to your handgun as well. vyq9w zn jvztxv qu3bdjx ot ni 7wa rijy vxija ii4du2i